Black Cohosh and Menopause

0 Recommendations

BLACK COHOSH root by Ray Sahelian, M.D.

Black cohosh (cimicifuga racemosa), also known as snakeroot, bugbane and rattle weed, is native to eastern North America, and has historically been used by Native Americans for a variety of female conditions. Black cohosh contains a variety of phytoestrogens. The German Comminssion E has approved black cohosh for the treatment of menopause symptoms, premenstrual syndrome - pms, and dysmenorrhea, however they recommend treatment be limited to 6 months.
Studies with black cohosh root have shown inconsistent results in reducing hot flashes in postmenopausal women. However, a survey of women done at the University of San Francisco published in Feb 2002 indicated that women who use a combination of herbal remedies and estrogen were more satisfied in the outcome of their symptoms compared to women who used estrogen alone or herbs alone. The supplements used were black cohosh, ginkgo, and soy. A 2006 German study found the combination of St. John's wort and black cohosh to be helpful in women with menopause symptoms and depression.
At this time there is debate in the herbal community on the role and effectiveness of black cohosh in treating female conditions, but it appears that this herb could play a positive role. Historically black cohosh has been used to treat some symptoms of menopause.

7 replies

Hi,

Just thought I'd let you know, my doctor insisted I stop taking St.Johns wort and Black cohosh, both worked brilliantly together and hot flushes were not a problem. When I stopped them I had a double whammy, the statins caused fierce flushes through the night as well as severe muscle cramps. I'm off statins and now take Agnus castus and Red clover, flushes under control, only one or two mild ones in a day. Thank goodness!
Grace x

Want to know more about balancing your hormones??? This man helped me out naturally when I only had 6 periods a year for 20 years. Go to www.johnleedmd.com He has written the books " WHAT YOUR DOCTOR MAY NOT TELL YOU ABOUT MENOPAUSE /PREMENOPAUSE There is a hormone test section that allows you to tell where your symptoms are coming from ... estrogen dominance or progesterone deficiency.

Here is some basic information about the effects of progesterone and estrogen

Effects of Progesterone & Estrogen



Excerpted From:

WHAT YOUR DOCTOR MAY NOT TELL YOU ABOUT BREAST CANCER:
Balance Your Hormones and Your Life from Thirty to Fifty

PHYSIOLOGICAL EFFECTS OF ESTROGEN AND PROGESTERONE

Estrogen Effects

Creates proliferative endometrium

Breast cell stimulation (fibrocystic breasts*)

Increased body fat and weight gain*

Salt and fluid retention

Depression, anxiety, and headaches*

Cyclical migraines*

Poor sleep patterns*

Interferes with thyroid hormone function*

Impairs blood sugar control*

Increased risk of blood clots*

Little or no libido effect*

Loss of zinc and retention of copper*

Reduced oxygen levels in all cells*

Causes endometrial cancer*

Increased risk of breast cancer*

Increased risk of prostate cancer*

Restrains bone loss

Reduces vascular tone (dilates blood vessels)

Triggers autoimmune diseases*

Creates progesterone receptors

Relieves hot flashes***

Prevents vaginal dryness & mucosal atrophy***

Increases risk of gall bladder disease*

Improves memory***

Improves sleep disorders***

Improves health of urinary tract***

Relieves night sweats***



Progesterone Effects

Maintains secretory endometrium

Protects against breast fibrocysts

Helps use fat for energy

Natural diuretic

Natural anti-depressant & calms anxiety

Prevents cyclical migraines

Promotes normal sleep patterns

Facilitates thyroid hormone function

Helps normalize blood sugar levels

Normalizes blood clotting

Helps restores normal libido

Normalizes zinc and copper levels

Restores proper cell oxygen levels

Prevents endometrial cancer

Helps prevent breast cancer1

Decreased risk of prostate cancer

Stimulates new bone formation

Improves vascular tone

Prevents autoimmune diseases

Increases sensitivity of estrogen receptors

Necessary for survival of embryo

Precursor of corticosteroid biosynthesis

Prevents coronary artery spasm and

atherosclerotic plaque.

Sleepiness, depression**

Digestive problems**


* Indicates that these effects are caused by estrogen dominance, or an imbalance of estrogen caused by too little progesterone.

** Indicates that these effects are caused by an excess of progesterone.

*** Indicates that these effects are caused by a deficiency of estrogen.

© Copyright, Warner Books 1999. This material may not be reproduced in any form without written permission of the author.







What Your Doctor May Not Tell You About Breast Cancer

NOW IN PAPERBACK!
How Hormone Balance Can Help Save Your Life
by John R. Lee, M.D., David Zava, Ph.D. and Virginia Hopkins.
Warner Books 2002 (410 Pages)

Another pioneering book by John R. Lee, M.D

Thank you, Kathi,

This is an important issue for women with heart disease.

Sherrie

When I was hospitalized for what turned out to be atrial fibrillation, I was taken off black cohosh. My hot flashes were not too bad, so I did not mind. Be sure to let your doctors know about any herbs you might be taking.

Dear Dee Dee,

Well, Black Cohosh is certainly not known for causing atrial fibrillation. Of course your doctors would rule it out in order to resolve the cause of your heart problem, as they would any other factor.

It seems to me that doctors are only too willing to prescribe chemical HRTs to women at the drop of a hat for menopausal symptoms--knowing full well they make heart disease worse and can even cause fatal heart attacks. Many women taking HRTs don't know they have heart disease until they experience a devastating cardiac event.

But for a medical doctor in the U.S. to recommend Black Cohosh, or soy products, or yams for menopause--you have got to be kidding!

Many women on this board have made statements that they will not ingest a substance that is not FDA approved. Well--Vioxx was FDA approved and it CAUSES heart attacks. The FDA, pharamaceutical companies, and doctors are in cahoots.

I agree with your statement however, if in question, consult with your doctor or pharmacist.

Sherrie

I never said that the black cohosh caused the atrial fibrillation. I just meant that with my medical history and medications I was taking, they felt it was not a good choice for me. My gynecologist had recommended the black cohosh. I believe that it is important for all doctors to look at the whole person and the whole medical history. Many doctors just focus on an individual problem.

Dear Dee Dee,

I hope you read the article on Fosomax. I was thinking of you and pray that you are not taking it.

Yes, doctors have a tendency to view us in parts and not as a whole.

Thank you for your comments.

May the Blessings Be!

Sherrie

Add to the discussion

New user? Join here.
Forgot password?
Keep me signed in on this computer until I sign out

Search

Find information and discussion about health topics in 294,905 posts by members like yourself. Learn more...

Join

Join safe, secure groups sponsored by trusted organizations that care about your health. Learn more...

Connect

Connect with 80,073 members and make friends who share your interests, learn about conditions and treatments, find support and more. Learn more...

You